Attention Activism: A Liberation Movement to Combat the Societal Attention Crisis - But For Real podcast #50

The attention economy is stealing more than our time. Here's why reclaiming our focus is a collective mental health issue, not another self-improvement project.

Think about the last time you picked up your phone to do ONE specific thing. Maybe you needed to check the weather, respond to a text, or look up whether that actor from the show you're watching was also in that OTHER show you watched six years ago. Fast-forward 20 minutes, and you're watching a woman in Nebraska organize her refrigerator while vaguely wondering what happened to your original mission. Sound familiar?

For many of us, this increasingly fragmented relationship with our attention has become a real problem. And not just because we're struggling to finish a book or sit through a movie without simultaneously checking our phones. Our attention is one of the most valuable resources we have, yet it's also become one of the most aggressively exploited. In this episode of But For Real, Valerie Martin and Emerson Ryder dive into something they've become particularly interested in lately: attention activism, a growing movement that recognizes our collective attention crisis as a systemic problem requiring collective solutions. Because while putting your phone on Do Not Disturb might help, we're going to need a hell of a lot more than app timers to address what's happening here.

The Attention Economy: When Your Brain Becomes the Product

We've all heard warnings that our attention spans are shrinking. And while the research is more complicated than the occasional viral statistic would suggest, there's no denying that our technological environment has fundamentally transformed how we engage with information, other people, and the world around us. Constant interruptions have become so normalized that we barely notice how frequently our attention is being redirected.

a row of people sitting looking at their phones

Here's the thing: our increasingly fractured attention isn't simply an unfortunate side effect of modern technology. It's also an extraordinarily profitable business model. Many digital platforms are designed to maximize engagement because the more time you spend scrolling, clicking, and watching, the more opportunities these companies have to collect data and generate advertising revenue.

Think about infinite scroll, push notifications, personalized recommendations, and videos that play automatically before you've consciously decided whether you want to watch them. These features are part of a technological ecosystem built around capturing and retaining your attention, often by exploiting predictable aspects of human psychology. Yet when we struggle to resist these systems, we tend to blame ourselves. We decide we lack discipline, that our brains are broken, or that we need a better morning routine and a more sophisticated productivity app. There's something deeply absurd about expecting individual willpower to consistently outperform technologies specifically designed to circumvent it. What if the problem isn't that we're failing to pay attention, but that our attention is being systematically harvested?

WTF Is Attention Activism?

Attention activism is a growing movement focused on protecting human attention from exploitation and reclaiming our ability to direct it toward what actually matters. In preparing for this episode, Val started taking a course through the Strother School of Radical Attention (SORA), a Brooklyn-based nonprofit helping cultivate this movement. The experience deepened her interest in understanding attention not simply as an individual psychological capacity, but as something shaped by larger social and economic forces. What makes SORA's approach particularly compelling is that it doesn't frame our attention crisis as another opportunity for self-improvement. It's not about becoming a hyperproductive machine who can concentrate for eight uninterrupted hours while drinking mushroom coffee and maintaining a 47-day meditation streak. Instead, it's about recognizing that our capacity to notice, wonder, connect, reflect, and make meaningful choices deserves protection.

Perhaps most importantly, attention activism recognizes that we cannot solve a systemic problem through individual behavioral changes alone. Consider how we've approached other societal threats: we don't expect every individual to independently determine which medications are safe or whether their drinking water contains dangerous chemicals. We have collective protections, regulations, educational initiatives, and organized advocacy because we recognize that these issues affect everyone. So why aren't we treating the exploitation of human attention with a similar level of seriousness?

We're Losing More Than Our Ability to Concentrate

One of the concepts explored in the episode comes from philosopher James Williams, who describes three different levels of attention: spotlight, starlight, and daylight. This framework offers a much richer understanding of what's at stake than the usual conversation about shrinking attention spans.

  • Spotlight is your immediate attention, or whatever you're focused on in this particular moment. It's what allows you to read this article, have a conversation, or complete something at work. When a notification interrupts your concentration or you instinctively switch tabs halfway through a task, that's a disruption of your spotlight attention.

  • Starlight is your ability to make choices that align with your bigger-picture goals and values. Maybe you value deep relationships, creativity, community involvement, or spending time outdoors. Starlight helps you maintain a connection to those priorities even when other demands are competing for your time and energy.

  • And then there's daylight, the deepest level of attention. This is your capacity to step back and determine what your values and goals even ARE, rather than simply pursuing whatever you've been conditioned to believe you should want. It's the mental space required for reflection, self-understanding, and questioning your assumptions about what constitutes a meaningful life.

When we talk about technology disrupting our attention, we usually focus on the spotlight. We lost 30 minutes scrolling instead of reading, couldn't concentrate during a meeting, or checked our phones a dozen times during dinner. But what happens when those interruptions become so constant that we rarely have the mental space to engage with our starlight and daylight? From their perspectives as therapists, Val and Emerson find this aspect of the attention crisis particularly compelling. Meaningful mental health isn't simply about reducing symptoms or becoming more efficient; it's about living with greater awareness, authenticity, connection, and freedom. When we lose the ability to intentionally direct our attention, we risk losing some of our ability to intentionally direct our lives.

Not All Attention Has to Be Productive

We've become so accustomed to evaluating attention through the lens of productivity that we often assume focused attention is inherently good and distracted attention is inherently bad. But there are many ways of engaging with the world, and not all of them need to involve sustained concentration on a particular task.

Consider the experience of flow, when you become completely absorbed in an activity. That can be wonderful when you're making art, writing, or engaged in meaningful work. But that same intense absorption can become problematic if you've spent six hours hyperfocused on something while forgetting to eat or hydrate. Our ADHD friends know exactly what we're talking about. Similarly, letting your mind wander isn't automatically evidence of poor attention. Daydreaming, noticing unexpected details in your environment, and following your curiosity can all be meaningful experiences. Some of our most interesting ideas emerge when we're not trying so damn hard to direct our thoughts toward a specific outcome.

This is part of why Emerson shared the concept of the dérive, a practice associated with French philosopher Guy Debord. Essentially, it's the art of wandering without a predetermined destination, allowing yourself to be guided by whatever catches your interest along the way. Emerson described experiencing this while wandering around London with her boyfriend, and how unexpectedly lovely it felt to explore without needing to accomplish anything. Their conversation raises an interesting question about how rarely modern life allows for that kind of experience. Even our leisure time has become something we're supposed to optimize, whether we're tracking our steps, measuring our recovery, or wondering whether we could monetize a hobby.

One of the most radical things we might do in a culture obsessed with productivity is reclaim the freedom to pay attention without needing that attention to produce something. Sometimes it's enough to simply be curious, engaged, and present for whatever unfolds.

The Mental Health Cost of Constant Distraction

When we think about the relationship between technology and mental health, the conversation often centers on social comparison, anxiety, or excessive screen time. Those are important considerations, but the attention crisis has implications beyond the number of hours we spend looking at screens. It also influences our capacity to be present in our relationships, connect with our internal experiences, and engage meaningfully with the world around us. Think about how frequently we're pulled away from our direct experience. You might be spending time with someone you love while part of your mind is tracking notifications, or trying to enjoy a quiet evening while feeling compelled to check the news again. For many of us, constant stimulation has become so normalized that the absence of stimulation feels uncomfortable.

a woman outside looks distressed while holding her phone

When we're uncomfortable, one of the easiest things to do is reach for the phone. It's an understandable cycle, especially when we're stressed, overwhelmed, lonely, or exhausted. But if we're constantly filling every available moment with external input, we may have fewer opportunities to notice what we're actually experiencing internally. We need space to feel our feelings, reflect on our relationships, sit with uncertainty, and reconnect with our bodies and surroundings. Even boredom, which we've become remarkably skilled at eliminating, can create opportunities for curiosity and self-reflection.

None of this means technology is inherently bad or that everyone needs to abandon their smartphone and move into a cabin in the woods. There are genuinely wonderful aspects of digital life, including access to information, creative expression, community, accessibility, and connection. The goal isn't technological purity; it's developing a more intentional relationship with the technologies we use while also questioning the systems shaping that relationship.

Personal Responsibility Without the Shame Spiral

During the Step Into My Office segment, Val and Emerson heard from a listener who works in social media marketing for a small business. She genuinely enjoys her job, but she's becoming increasingly uncomfortable with how much her professional attention to engagement metrics has spilled into her personal life. She catches herself thinking about whether posts are performing while spending time with her husband, and her daughter recently told her that she looks at her phone more than she looks at her.

Oof. That kind of moment can bring up a LOT of guilt, particularly when you already recognize that your relationship with technology isn't working the way you'd like it to. But Val and Emerson approached her dilemma with nuance rather than treating her work as inherently harmful or suggesting that the only ethical solution is to leave her profession. Social media isn't exclusively a source of manipulation and disconnection. It can also help ethical businesses reach customers, connect people with resources, and create genuinely joyful experiences. There is a meaningful difference between creating valuable content and designing content primarily to exploit people's psychological vulnerabilities, even if the boundaries aren't always perfectly clear.

Recognizing the systemic nature of the attention economy doesn't mean we have no responsibility for our own choices. We can acknowledge the pressures these technologies create while reflecting on how we engage with them, the boundaries we establish, and the ways our habits affect the people around us. What isn't reasonable is placing the entire burden on individuals while leaving the underlying systems unquestioned. The conversation highlights an important distinction that applies to mental health more broadly: we can have compassion without complacency, and agency without shame.

Reclaiming Your Attention Without Another Self-Improvement Project

One of Emerson's recurring philosophies lately has been less is more. Less overthinking, less optimizing, and less constantly trying to improve every aspect of existence. It's a particularly helpful mindset for approaching attention reclamation, because the last thing anyone needs is to turn it into another elaborate wellness regimen that makes them feel like a failure when they inevitably fall off track. Rather than attempting a complete digital overhaul, we can start by noticing our existing habits and experimenting with small changes. Maybe that means spending the first five minutes of your morning without immediately reaching for your phone, taking a walk without a predetermined route, or having a phone-free meal with someone you love.

Technology itself can be helpful in creating these boundaries, too. Val has experimented with an app called Jomo to limit access to certain platforms, finding that it can create some much-needed breathing room even without perfect consistency. The idea isn't to find a flawless system that eliminates every distraction, but to make it a little easier to act in alignment with how we actually want to spend our time. Another useful practice is simply becoming curious about what prompts us to reach for our phones. Are we looking for information, seeking connection, avoiding discomfort, or responding to a habit that's become so automatic we barely notice it? There doesn't need to be judgment attached to the answer, but developing awareness gives us more opportunities to make intentional choices.

And please, let's leave perfectionism out of this. There will probably be days when you spend way more time on your phone than you intended, and that's part of being human in a world designed to compete for your attention. Reclaiming attention isn't about achieving some mythical state of flawless mindfulness; it's about gradually expanding our freedom to decide where our attention goes.

The SOS Framework: Study, Organizing, and Sanctuary

One of the frameworks Val highlights from the Strother School of Radical Attention is its SOS framework, which offers three interconnected ways to participate in attention activism: Study, Organizing, and Sanctuary. Rather than focusing exclusively on personal habits, the framework encourages people to learn together, build collective power, and create environments where our attention can flourish.

Study

Study involves getting curious about how attention works, how it's shaped by our environments, and why protecting it matters. Importantly, SORA emphasizes studying together rather than treating attention as another subject we're supposed to master independently. Through her own attention activism coursework, Val has experienced the value of this collective approach. It's one thing to read an article independently, but another to discuss it with a group of thoughtful humans and discover perspectives you never would have considered on your own. Those conversations help participants move beyond their individual experiences and better understand the larger forces influencing our collective attention.

Organizing

Organizing focuses on building collective power to protect attention as a shared resource. This might involve education, community initiatives, advocacy, public conversations, and policies that hold powerful technology companies accountable for harmful design practices. Our relationship with technology is shaped not only by personal choices, but also by economic incentives and political decisions. Just because certain technological practices have become normalized doesn't mean we have to accept them as permanent features of modern life. Organizing allows communities to imagine alternatives and work toward environments that better support human wellbeing.

Sanctuary

Sanctuary means intentionally creating spaces where human attention can flourish without being constantly interrupted, monitored, or monetized. That could look like phone-free dinners, community gatherings, reading groups, shared walks, or other spaces that encourage genuine presence. We've seen examples of this in comedy clubs that require audiences to lock away their phones during performances. Sure, some people find that annoying, but there's something freeing about collectively agreeing that, for this particular experience, everyone can be present without the constant demands of their devices.

What if there were more spaces like that? What if being fully present became something we supported each other in doing, rather than another individual challenge we had to overcome?

Attention Is a Social Justice Issue, Too!

There's another important layer to this conversation: not everyone has the same resources, flexibility, or freedom to disconnect. Some people rely on digital platforms for work, accessibility, community, safety, or connection with people they cannot easily reach in person. Others have jobs that require constant responsiveness or caregiving responsibilities that make being unreachable impractical.

For marginalized communities in particular, online spaces can provide meaningful belonging and access to resources that aren't available locally. A simplistic message of just delete social media ignores these realities and risks turning attention into another form of privilege. The ability to protect our attention shouldn't be available only to people with enough money, time, and occupational flexibility to opt out. That's another reason the collective aspect of attention activism matters so much. We need to think beyond individual screen-time habits and ask bigger questions about technological accountability, access, education, workplace expectations, and the right to meaningful autonomy.

Val also makes the case for attentional literacy becoming a more prominent part of education, right alongside media and financial literacy. Imagine helping young people understand not only how digital platforms work, but also how those platforms compete for their attention and influence their choices. A culture that recognizes attention as something worth protecting, rather than an endlessly extractable resource, would represent a meaningful shift in how we approach technology and wellbeing.

Your Attention Belongs to You

At the heart of this conversation is a question that extends well beyond technology: What do you want to give your life to? Not just your working hours or your productivity, but your actual, finite, precious experience of being alive. What do you want to notice, who do you want to connect with, and what deserves your curiosity, compassion, creativity, and care?

a group of women dancing and smiling surrounded by confetti

Throughout the episode, Val and Emerson explore how attention is intimately connected to our capacity for meaning-making, authentic relationships, and collective action. Those capacities are central to what makes us human, and they deserve more consideration than they're often given in conversations about digital wellbeing. The bigger question isn't simply how to improve concentration, but how to create lives and communities that allow people to be more fully present. The attention crisis is a serious issue, but it doesn't have to be approached with despair, shame, or another list of impossible expectations. There's room for curiosity, compassion, collective action, and even a little joy. Because ultimately, reclaiming our attention isn't about becoming better consumers, better workers, or more efficient versions of ourselves. It's about becoming more fully present in our own lives.

And that seems pretty damn worthwhile ❤️‍🔥

Previous
Previous

Your Pelvic Floor Is Probably Trying to Tell You Something (And No, Kegels Aren’t Always the Answer) - But For Real podcast #51

Next
Next

Body Positivity, Body Neutrality, and the Current Cultural Backslide of Fatphobia